In Utah, Catholics, Mormons have long had 'positive, cordial relationship'

Friday, Mar. 22, 2019

SALT LAKE CITY— The March 3 meeting at the Vatican between Pope Francis and Russell M. Nelson, president of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (widely known as the Mormon church), drew great interest from members of both faiths.  

This historic meeting, the first between the leaders of the two churches, came about while Nelson and other leaders of his faith were in Rome to dedicate a church temple, the first in Italy. Church temples are where sacred ordinances of the faith are conducted.

The temple was built as a response to divine revelation, to give the church’s nearly 27,000 members in Italy access to those ordinances, and because Rome has historically been “the heart and center of the Christian world,” said John Taylor, director of Interfaith Relations for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

Vatican leaders, in particular Cardinal Jean-Louis Tauran, who was president of the Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialogue until his death last year, have been very supportive of his church’s efforts to build the temple in Rome, Taylor said. 

While historically the two churches have interacted positively, some see the meeting as the beginning of a new chapter in their relationship.

“This says to me that Mormons and Catholics are getting to know each other as Christians,” Mathew Schmalz, a College of the Holy Cross associate professor of religious studies, said. “Beyond political action, they are getting to know each other as people of faith. I think it could provide the opportunity for more substantial dialogue in religious issues that moves beyond mutual stereotypes.”

Schmalz has written and spoken extensively about Mormon/Catholic dialogue and is the only Catholic on the editorial board of Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought, an independent quarterly journal.

Utah became home to The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in 1847 as its members settled here in hopes of finding a place where they could practice their faith without persecution. (The tenets of the religion were unpopular in the eastern states where the church first organized.) 

While the first Mass was celebrated in Utah in 1776 by members of the Dominguez-Escalante party, who were seeking an overland route from present-day New Mexico to California, the Catholic Church formally came to Utah with the creation of the Vicariate Apostolic of Utah in 1886; the Diocese of Salt Lake City was established in 1891.   

In time, both churches grew and flourished side by side on this desert frontier, but while each church professes a deep belief in the person of Jesus Christ as the savior of mankind, distinctly different doctrines and practices have historically kept the faithful separate. Nevertheless, over the years, the leadership of the two churches met often but it was always behind closed doors, according to Diocese of Salt Lake City Vicar General Monsignor Colin M. Bircumshaw. 

“The differences were in the pews,” he said. “We’ve had a positive and cordial relationship for many years. We have mutually recognized theological differences, but we don’t let them deter us from working together and respecting one another. We’ve especially worked closely together in common areas of social justice and charitable projects.” 

Locally, the LDS Church has proven to be a strong partner with Catholic Community Services of Utah, the local arm of Catholic Charities, USA.

“Not only do they support us with in-kind and monetary donations, but also with volunteers,” CCS Executive Director Bradford R. Drake said. “Their manpower is invaluable as each of our programs rely on thousands of volunteers each year to meet the needs of those we serve. … We consider ourselves very fortunate to work with The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, whose focus is very similar to ours in following Christ’s example of serving those most in need.” 

On a national level, since the 1980s, LDS Charities, the church’s humanitarian arm, has had an on ongoing relationship with Catholic Relief Services. It began when the Most Reverend William K. Weigand, seventh Bishop of Salt Lake City, facilitated a partnership between LDS Charities and CRS to provide aid to Poland during the early days of Solidarity, the people’s labor movement in that country. Since that time, CRS and LDS Charities have partnered in hundreds of humanitarian and development projects across the world. 

“From 2014 to 2018, LDS Charities supported more than 50 CRS projects, which reached more than 1.7 million people,” CRS CEO Sean Callahan said. “Currently, LDS Charities is supporting 24 active CRS projects, which touch all major regions of Africa, the Middle East, East and South Asia, and Central and South America. This is more than a relationship between two charities, it’s a relationship between faith communities dedicated to reaching out to our sisters and brothers globally.” 

While the leadership of both churches has been actively engaged together in humanitarian efforts for many years, for much of their shared history in Utah the ordinary members of the churches rarely interacted except in the workforce. In recent years that has changed. For example, parishes and LDS wards throughout the state often assist each other on food drives and other charitable efforts. Also, as attacks on organized religion and traditional values have mounted, common core values have led to greater interaction and dialogue between local faith congregations, including the two churches.  

Leaders of the two churches have continued to meet often to address areas of mutual concern. One issue that Taylor said comes up at just about every meeting in recent years is how to engage young people who are drifting away from their parents’ faith.

Taylor said they are learning together that while these young people often describe themselves as religiously unaffiliated or “none” on surveys, they are very concerned about causes.

The charitable work of both churches is the perfect vehicle to draw those young people back into their faith communities, Taylor said. “It is amazing to me to see that when we organize an activity or event along those lines there is an incredibly strong response that comes from that segment.” 

As both churches address this and other concerns, “I have no question that the commonalities between the two faiths can overcome the differences that separate us,” he said.